Judge: Pistorius did not intentionally kill

By admin on 11/09/2014

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon

Views: 896


Oscar Pistorius cleared of first charge

Pretoria, South Africa (CNN) - Oscar Pistorius cannot be found guilty of intentionally killing Reeva Steenkamp, the judge in his trial saidThursday. The judge has not issued a verdict, and the proceedings continue. Pistorius faces other possible verdicts, including culpable homicide.

Under South African law, Pistorius will not be found guilty of "murder."

Pistorius could not have foreseen that the person he was shooting at, who was behind the bathroom door, would die, and therefore the state has not proven an intent to kill, Judge Thokozile Masipa said.

She also said evidence suggests that Pistorius genuinely believed his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp was still in the bedroom, and that the person in the bathroom was an intruder, although that is irrelevant to the case, she said.

Pistorius' trial started six months ago, transfixing the world with graphic details of how he fatally shot Steenkamp.

Before she rejected the premeditated murder charge, Judge Thokozile Masipa questioned why he fired "not one ... but four shots" into the bathroom before he went to find his girlfriend.

However, she said, the intention to shoot does not necessarily mean the intent to kill.

"Court is satisfied that at the relevant time, the accused could distinguish between right and wrong" and act accordingly, she said.

Shorly before, Masipa cast doubt on witness testimony, and said she believes media coverage contaminated testimonies. She doubted state witnesses, saying they were in and out of sleep the night of the killing on Valentine's Day last year.

"Technology is more reliable than human perception and human memory," she said.

She described the victim's wound as "immediately incapacitating," and said she believed a scream heard by witnesses the night of the killing was Pistorius,' not Steenkamp's.

The judge appeared to be accepting the defense timeline of events that the shots came first, then screaming that must have been Pistorius.

She knocked down some aspects of the state's case: the fact that Steenkamp took her phone and locked herself in the bathroom allegedly out of fear for her safety, phone messages between the couple that showed some rocky patches, and her stomach contents.

Steenkamp's parents, Barry and June Steenkamp, sat expressionless a few rows behind the man on trial for killing their daughter. Her father bowed his head as he heard about his daughter's fatal wounds.

Pistorius' uncle, sister and brother also attended the hearing in the packed courtroom -- the latter in a wheel chair from a car accident.

Heaving sobs

The verdict will cap a dramatic trial that started in March, and featured months of gory details that have seen Pistorius gag, vomit and break down in heaving sobs.

He fatally shot his law graduate girlfriend on Valentine's Day last year at his home in South Africa.

Prosecutors charged him with premeditated murder, but he maintains he mistook her for an intruder when he fired four shots through a locked bathroom door.

South Africa does not have jury trials, and Masipa must decide: Did he intentionally kill Steenkamp? Was it murder?

In addition to the murder charge, Pistorius faces three other weapons charges.

Lesser charges

Of the additional three charges, the most serious one is related to ammunition found in his house when police searched it after the killing.

He did not have a proper license for it, but he maintains he was storing it in his safe for his father.

If he is found guilty of the ammunition charge, he could face up to 15 years in prison, though the judge could opt for a lesser punishment such as a fine or the loss of his gun license.

Two other charges are related to allegations that he recklessly fired a gun in public -- once in a restaurant in 2012, and again out of the sunroof of a car last year. Pistorius denies both.

The maximum penalty for each charge is five years behind bars. If he is convicted of either, he could face a lesser sentence, such as a fine or the loss of his gun license.

Murder charge

If the judge finds him guilty of murder, she must then decide if it's premeditated. A minimum sentence for premeditated murder is life. A minimum sentence for murder with no previous convictions is 15 years.

Pistorius argues he made a mistake and was trying to defend himself from an intruder. If Masipa accepts that as plausible, she will then have to decide if his mistake and his actions were reasonable.

If she says they were not, she'll find him guilty of a crime called culpable homicide. There is no minimum sentence for culpable homicide in South African law -- it's up to the judge to decide.

And there's one final possibility.

If the judge does not think the prosecution has proved its case, she will find him not guilty, and Pistorius will be a free man.

Masipa will make her decision with the assistance of two experts known as assessors.

 

Source cnn

Posted on September, 11 2014

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon


You may also like...
Abia House of Assembly Passes States 2014 Audit...

Akwa Ibom Church tragedy: We're with you in...

Suarez inspires Barcelona comeback

Nigeria Ends Fifth Tenure On UN Security Council...

ISIL re-enters Syrian Kurdish town Kobane

Ikpeazu flags off construction of 170 km rural...

Sack ABSUTH, ABIAPOLY, ABIALINE managment, Labour tells Ikpeazu...

Buhari's visit: LASG declares Thurday work free day...

National Assembly increase budget to #120B

Afikpo Chic Suspended by Ebonyi Assembly

ABIA PDP LEGAL TEAM DISSOCIATES PARTY FROM INEC...

Arraign or free Commissioner, Accountant - Ekiti Govt...
News Abia Election Special (3) Abia Supplementary Polls Update (18) Abia Supplementary Result update (22) Appointments (8) Breaking News (195) Business (32) Campus News (3) Crime (91) Economy (96) Education (108) Entertainment (138) Fashion and Style (3) General (702) Health (101) Inside Africa (39) International News (302) Interviews (24) National (1814) Politics (759) Press Releases (102) Religion (9) Security (115) Sports (416) Technology (22) World News (87)

 

 

Advertisement

 

Latest News You have destroyed your own people and shamed them before the world, FFK tells Buhari Stolen Senate mace recovered near Abuja City Gate 4,562 newly-recruited teachers sacked in Kaduna I will never refer to Nigeria’s youth as Lazy - Atiku Sex-for-Mark scandal: Committee recommends indefinite suspension of Prof. Akindele Free School Feeding: Ikpeazu empowers 270 Food Vendors Abia Yet To Record New Case Of Lassa Fever - NMA Senate invasion, sign that Buhari’s govt is broken – Secondus Attack on Senate is terrorism – Reps Senate:Pandemonium as Thugs made away with Mace

 

Most Read Islamic agenda for Nigeria – Pastor Bosun (21,598 views) The show of shame that sealed Justice Uzokwe’s fate (17,145 views) 47 YEARS AFTER, HIS EXCELLENCY, COMMODORE EBITU UKIWE (Rtd) MAKES THE “OFO NDI IGBO” RECIPIENTS LIST (13,670 views) Breaking News : Dr Okezie Ikpeazu resigns from Abia State Environmental Sanitation Agency (ASEPA). (7,024 views) Radio Biafra delivers AM Transmitter (6,469 views) ‘Why fuel scarcity persists’ (5,203 views) Nurse Justina Obi Ejelonu, one of the nurses that contracted Ebola virus is dead!!! (5,153 views) Breaking News : 2015 - Abaribe withdraws from Abia guber race, backs Ikpeazu (4,939 views) 2015: Abia’s plethora of governorship aspirants (4,912 views) Abia Re-run/Supplementary polls: SEPA cautions Inec, military against manipulations of results (4,864 views)