Gov. Ayade wins at supreme Court

By FactNews on 10/12/2016

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon

Views: 981

Governor Ben Ayade of Cross River State has won his case at the supreme Court as S-court upheld his election.

The court, in a unanimous judgment by a five-man panel, dismissed an appeal raised by a lawyer, Joe Agi (SAN) against an earlier decision of the Court of Appeal, which upheld Ayade’s election.

Agi had participated in the governorship primary of the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) on December 8, 2014, from which Ayade emerged as the party’s candidate for the 2015 election.

Agi later challenged Ayade’s victory in the primary and his eventual victory at the election, raising issues of age and party membership.

It was Agi’s contention at the trial court that Ayade was not a valid member of the PDP, as at when he participated in the primary, because he allegedly defaulted in his dues.

Agi also queried Ayade’s candidacy on the ground that he falsified his age.

He claimed that Ayade falsely represented his date of birth in his nomination form submitted to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) and other records as March 2, 1968 and March 2, 1969.

He sought Ayade’s disqualification on those grounds, and prayed the court to among others, disqualify Ayade and void his election.

The Federal High Court, Abuja dismissed the suit for lacking in merit. Agi appealed to the Court of Appeal in Abuja, which, in a judgment on February 5, 2016, also dismissed the appeal, a decision Agi later appealed to the Supreme Court.

Justice Clara Ogunbiyi, who read the lead judgement of the Supreme Court Friday, said it was not the responsibility of the court to determine who is a member of a political party.


The Judge said political parties are like voluntary association and that the issue of determining who is a member is internal to the political party.

She said since there were evidences that the PDP cleared Ayade to contest election as its candidate, it was not for the court to begin to inquire how the party arrived at its decision.

On the issue of age, Justice Ogunbiyi said since the discrepancies noted in Ayade’s documents were not intended to circumvent the constitutional requirement of 35 years (for a person ruling for governorship position), they were immaterial.

She noted that age falsification was criminal offence, which needed to be adequately proved by the person making such allegation.

Justice Ogunbiyi said the status of a person’s membership of a political party was not “justiciable,” and that since the party, through its state Secretary, confirmed at the trial court that Ayade had paid all his dues and that he remained a member of the party, the court could not hold otherwise.

She said: “The pertinent question to pose is that who between the appellant (Agi) and the first respondent (the PDP) has the vires to decide who is a member of the party.”

The judge noted that contrary to Agi’s submission, the endorsement of the word “cleared” on Ayade’s membership card, was sufficient to show that he (Ayade) had paid all necessary dues as stipulated in section 8(10) of PDP’s constitution.


She noted that as provided under paragraph 48 of the of the PDP’s Guideline for Primary Election 2014, the party’s National Executive Committee’s (NEC’s) decision, conveyed by the state chapter of the party, to the effect that Ayade was a member of the party, was final and binding on all aspirants, who participated in the December 8, 2014 primary.

Justice Ogunbiyi said: “As I earlier said, a political party is a voluntary association and its decision is binding on its members even if it is deemed unreasonable.The decision of the party on issue like this is final.

“The court will not substitute its will with that of the voluntary association, whether it is reasonable or unreasonable.”

Justice Ogunbiyi, who noted the allegation of age falsification “is rooted” in criminality, said Agi failed to prove his allegation that Ayade falsified his age beyond reasonable doubt as required by law.

The judge said for age falsification to serve as a disqualifying factor for any person contesting for the office of governor, it must be proved that it was done with the intention to meet the minimum age of 35 years, which is the constitutional requirement for any person seeking to occupy the office of governor.

Justice Ogunbiyi said that neither of disputed the dates of birth (March 2, 1968 and March 2, 1969), which placed the age of the governor at either 45 or 46 as of the time he was nominated by the PDP to run for the office of the governor, conferred any undue advantage on him.

“The second respondent (Ayade) was said to have stated his date of birth in his nomination form to INEC as March 2, 1968.

“That means that he was 46 years old as of the time he was nominated and that was 11 years above the constitutional requirement of 35 years.

“By March 2, 1969, the second respondent would have been 45 years old as of the time he was sponsored by the first respondent (the PDP).

“He would still have been 10 years above the constitutional requirement age of 35 years for office of the governor.

“The appellant has failed to prove the intention of the second respondent to circumvent the law in order to ensure his compliance with constitutional age requirement,” Justice Ogunbiyi said.

The judge noted that sections 14(b) and 15(2) of the PDP’s constitution and Section 31(2),(5) and (6) of the Electoral Act (which provide for the disqualification of any aspirant seeking political office) were to ensure compliance with the requirement on mandatory age for the office of the governor under section 177(b) and section 182(1) of the Constitution.




Source The Nation

Posted on December, 10 2016

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon

You may also like...
Senate Passes Bill Criminalizing Female Genital Mutilation, Violence...

Man kills wife for committing Adultery in Niger...

12,000 Nigerians in Libya prisons, stranded

BREAKING: Another APGA Chieftain dumps party because of...

Winners of Abia PDP Primaries

Breaking News!!! Okezie Ikpeazu projected to win Abia...

#BBNaija: Marvis Strips down to Cover for House...

Army Ready To Expose Boko Haram Sponsors

Electoral Act: Honours more in breach.

CHAN Finals: Nigeria to play Morocco after defeating...

President Buhari To Head Petroleum Ministry For 18...

Buhari Not Interested in Peace, Working to Compromise...
News Abia Election Special (3) Abia Supplementary Polls Update (18) Abia Supplementary Result update (22) Appointments (8) Breaking News (196) Business (42) Campus News (3) Crime (124) Economy (112) Education (127) Entertainment (148) Fashion and Style (3) General (830) Health (109) Inside Africa (40) International News (303) Interviews (28) National (1946) Politics (970) Press Releases (116) Religion (9) Security (127) Sports (431) Technology (24) World News (87)





Latest News BREAKING: INEC releases final list of candidates for 2019 general elections Court orders Police to provide basis for detaining Dino Melaye Even if Pope is my running mate, Christians won’t vote for me - El-Rufai Buhari approves Adamu as acting IG as Idris bows out today I’m also hungry, Amaechi tells Nigerians at campaign rally Management of Abia Bailout funds and Paris Club refunds; Oshiomhole is confused CJN's Trial is illegal, it’ll end in prosecutorial misadventure –Falana Saraki says FG’s haste to arraign CJN shows corruption war is compromised CJN’s trial: N’Delta militants threaten to shut down oil wells Ignore CCT summons, South-South govs tell CJN


Most Read Islamic agenda for Nigeria – Pastor Bosun (24,156 views) The show of shame that sealed Justice Uzokwe’s fate (17,587 views) 47 YEARS AFTER, HIS EXCELLENCY, COMMODORE EBITU UKIWE (Rtd) MAKES THE “OFO NDI IGBO” RECIPIENTS LIST (17,206 views) Breaking News : Dr Okezie Ikpeazu resigns from Abia State Environmental Sanitation Agency (ASEPA). (7,750 views) Lawyers accuse Lagos Police of working for PDP (7,392 views) Radio Biafra delivers AM Transmitter (7,166 views) ‘Why fuel scarcity persists’ (6,199 views) Abiriba Kingdom Celebrates as Eze Kalu Kalu Ogbu (IV) marks 14th year on the throne (5,849 views) Nurse Justina Obi Ejelonu, one of the nurses that contracted Ebola virus is dead!!! (5,809 views) Breaking News : 2015 - Abaribe withdraws from Abia guber race, backs Ikpeazu (5,579 views)